Clinical Resiliency: Strategies for Preventing Burnout in Therapists
In this episode, Rob discusses clinical resiliency with Katie McCoog, LCSW and clinical director of Embark Behavioral Health in White Haven, Pennsylvania. Katie and Rob define resiliency as the ability to respond to one’s environment and bounce back from challenges. They emphasizes the importance of recognizing progress, setting boundaries, and seeking support from supervisors and therapists. Rob also highlights the concept of flow state, where therapists feel a sense of fulfillment and engagement in their work. Additionally, Katie and Rob address the impact of vicarious trauma and the need for self-care in the helping profession.
About Katie
Katie McCoog graduated from Marywood University with an MSW degree in Social Work, with a concentration in Behavioral Health. She has been working in the field for 15 years and has been acknowledged internationally as a certified trauma therapist. Katie has provided family and individual therapy, substance abuse, and behavior modification to a wide variety of populations such as children starting at the age of 5 to adults 60 and over. She has treated individuals diagnosed with autism, mental health illnesses, intellectual disabilities, and comorbidity.
About Rob
Dr. Rob Gent, who has a doctorate in psychology, is the vice president of clinical development and training and one of the founding members of Embark Behavioral Health. Rob has been with the company for 15 years and has led the Embark organization in clinical development and growth of numerous programs. He is the lead developer of the proprietary CASA Developmental Framework, which is pervasive throughout Embark’s programs.
Through his dedication to advancing clinical development, practice, and research, he has become a nationally recognized expert in the field. His specialization in clinical development is enhanced by his therapeutic expertise and has yielded such accomplishments as the development of; The CASA Developmental Framework, Vive Family Intensive Program, Calo Preteens, Canine Attachment Therapy-Transferable Attachment Program, and other specialized programs.
Connect with Embark on Social Media:
Have a question for our experts? We want to hear from you! Submit your questions to: [email protected]
Transcript
Welcome, everybody to another podcast Sessions of
Rob Gent:Sessions. Happy to have everybody as listeners, you know
Rob Gent:that we take time to be able to dive in and hear the stories.
Rob Gent:And clinically, we really get to investigate. And I personally
Rob Gent:love to hear from people who are professionals in the field to be
Rob Gent:able to talk about their experience and be able to glean
Rob Gent:that and help others out, who are other professionals or
Rob Gent:parents listening. So really excited to have Katie McCool.
Rob Gent:Today, join us, who is a clinical director at I'll let
Rob Gent:her introduce herself more, but she's one of our Clinical
Rob Gent:Directors at one of our short term residential centers in
Rob Gent:Pennsylvania, is that correct? Katie, tell us a little bit
Rob Gent:about exactly where you're at would be great. Sure.
Katie McCoog:So I am located in White Haven, Pennsylvania. That
Katie McCoog:is more like northeast PA, northeast
Rob Gent:PA and it's short term residential, maybe just give a
Rob Gent:description of what is that level of care versus other
Rob Gent:levels of care.
Katie McCoog:So short term residential, I like to call the
Katie McCoog:sweet spot, it's usually we like to be the medium before you have
Katie McCoog:to step into a higher level of care. Or if you're at a higher
Katie McCoog:level of care, it's right before you are discharging home to the
Katie McCoog:community. So our short term is somewhere between 75 and 90 days
Katie McCoog:stay. And it is intensive therapy. But we really use life
Katie McCoog:coaches and the staff to practice this experiential DBT
Katie McCoog:skills and other modalities that we have.
Rob Gent:Great. The reason I wanted you to talk about it is
Rob Gent:because I mean, for the average person hearing like the, the
Rob Gent:actual the clients come and live there, like they're there 24
Rob Gent:hours a day, that is really intensive, maybe it's talk a
Rob Gent:little bit about that. It's a pretty captive audience, I would
Rob Gent:imagine. It is,
Katie McCoog:um, it sounds really intensive. However, I
Katie McCoog:think that like our environment here is very homey. And we do
Katie McCoog:have like Coach staff that are here to support our students.
Katie McCoog:They're here 24 hours a day, seven days a week. And then we
Katie McCoog:have therapists here to help with individual and family
Katie McCoog:Sessions and group Sessions. It feels intense sometimes. But
Katie McCoog:really, once you start building those relationships with the
Katie McCoog:students and their families, it feels more like a family.
Rob Gent:Yeah, I appreciate you saying that. I love that family
Rob Gent:aspect. It's homey and, and some of the realities are is that
Rob Gent:because some of the behaviors, and the emotional illness is
Rob Gent:somewhat intense and acute, especially might, the behaviors
Rob Gent:might exceed being able to keep them safe at home. And so they
Rob Gent:actually need to be able to have that environment and immersion
Rob Gent:into that environment. And I guess the reason I wanted I like
Rob Gent:to talk about this and bring that up is there's lots of
Rob Gent:therapists like yourself, who it's it can be a very daunting,
Rob Gent:I should say, it's incredibly rewarding, I imagine but there
Rob Gent:it's it's a lot. It's a lot all the time. It's not like you see
Rob Gent:him for an hour, and then they then they go home. Yeah,
Katie McCoog:correct. I really feel like residential is its own
Katie McCoog:entity. It's not like outpatient at all. I mean, there are
Katie McCoog:intensive outpatient, right and PHPs. But every time you walk
Katie McCoog:into work, your students are here. You're living and growing
Katie McCoog:with them. So it is it can be pretty intense sometimes,
Katie McCoog:especially if one student is really struggling one day for
Katie McCoog:any reason. It can set off, you know, another student or we can
Katie McCoog:just be rallying around them like a community to help support
Katie McCoog:them as well.
Rob Gent:And plus, you're doing individual Sessions, you're
Rob Gent:doing family Sessions, you don't group Sessions. I know they go
Rob Gent:to school there, they do a bunch of things. And yeah, the reason
Rob Gent:I wanted to mention that is because our topic today is
Rob Gent:really talking about clinical resiliency. And talking about
Rob Gent:that's important because as you can imagine, we there's a lot of
Rob Gent:therapists too, and we'll talk about this word a little bit but
Rob Gent:use the term burnout. Burnout I know you've had I'm sure you've
Rob Gent:had some experiences with with that. So let's go ahead and
Rob Gent:climb in. Thanks for setting the stage. Katie, I really
Rob Gent:appreciate it and knowing that you're certainly an expert in
Rob Gent:understanding hi hi case loads intensive being a therapist with
Rob Gent:intensive students and wonderfully we have very
Rob Gent:involved parents. So that becomes its own can be a
Rob Gent:stressor in its own. Right. So if we can let's let's clinical
Rob Gent:resiliency we talked about this term resiliency is kind of out
Rob Gent:in the world. I don't know that it's defined real well people
Rob Gent:hear it but I So what are your thoughts on what? How would you
Rob Gent:define the term resiliency?
Katie McCoog:It's interesting that you asked me to define it.
Katie McCoog:In the midst of researching what resiliency really is based on
Katie McCoog:all of these different studies that have already been conducted
Katie McCoog:for multiple years. And then each person has their own
Katie McCoog:definition of what resiliency is, I find resiliency is the
Katie McCoog:ability to respond to your environments, or simply put,
Katie McCoog:like, the bouncing back part of it. So you have a situation and
Katie McCoog:what's your ability to kind of think about respond and then be
Katie McCoog:able to function through it?
Rob Gent:Oh, I like that definition. I appreciate that.
Rob Gent:So just building on that, I would agree with you, Katie,
Rob Gent:that there's been a lot of research on some of the research
Rob Gent:base that I've done in looking at I love this definition that
Rob Gent:they talked about resiliency, if you imagine that it is this sort
Rob Gent:of cycle, that if we move from a place of baseline of positive
Rob Gent:effect, that we can rely on that baseline as our Yeah, that's our
Rob Gent:baseline. And then as we experience negative effect, we
Rob Gent:actually circle through that and we get, we don't stay there. And
Rob Gent:then we can go ride that through and experience it. And it
Rob Gent:doesn't necessarily compensate us or dysregulated us to the
Rob Gent:point where, you know, we're disabled in some sort of way, or
Rob Gent:it's affecting our daily lives. And then we circle full back and
Rob Gent:return back to that positive baseline of effect. I like to
Rob Gent:use that term when talking about doing therapy with kids, because
Rob Gent:oftentimes we think about kids is we want them to be resilient,
Rob Gent:and how can I send my kid to you, and you guys really build
Rob Gent:their resiliency? And I always like to say, Well, if we use
Rob Gent:that definition, we end it is about a bouncing back and being
Rob Gent:able to do that. Oftentimes, we have to assess what is the
Rob Gent:baseline? Do they even have a baseline of positive effect or
Rob Gent:stability or regulation? I wonder if you have noticed that?
Rob Gent:Even with therapist do we have? Is that a helpful construct even
Rob Gent:for therapist,
Katie McCoog:I think I think therapists kind of set higher
Katie McCoog:expectations for themselves than they do for their own students
Katie McCoog:and families. And oftentimes, it's unrealistic, because they
Katie McCoog:just find themselves that they have to have a higher standard,
Katie McCoog:right? Like I'm the professional in the field. So I should be
Katie McCoog:able to fill in the blank. When really That's That's not fair.
Katie McCoog:Setting, what we teach and preach to our families and our
Katie McCoog:students, we should be able to absorb for ourselves. And
Katie McCoog:something that I love so much about resiliency, is that it's
Katie McCoog:it exists in every single culture and population. It's
Katie McCoog:just, it's spoken in a different language, maybe it looks
Katie McCoog:differently, but the the essence of resiliency is it's there,
Katie McCoog:it's present for everybody. But what does it look like for you,
Katie McCoog:and you should be the person that defines your own
Katie McCoog:resiliency? Interesting?
Rob Gent:Yeah. Like, I liked it. It's a universal concept.
Rob Gent:Yeah. And I also want to highlight what you said that, as
Rob Gent:therapists, they think we have these expectations of ourselves,
Rob Gent:to be able to endure and be there for everybody. And I mean,
Rob Gent:we're going to talk about vicarious trauma in a second,
Rob Gent:but you're constantly absorbing, especially if you're a
Rob Gent:relationally, attuned therapist, where there's a tremendous
Rob Gent:amount of empathy, and that that can certainly inhibit it. And I
Rob Gent:guess my point is, I wonder how much supervision do you have to
Rob Gent:do where you talk to a therapist and say, how do you have this
Rob Gent:baseline? How do you know how to get back to the baseline? Are
Rob Gent:you even familiar with the what the baseline feels like? And
Rob Gent:maybe that baseline I would, I would use the term rep
Rob Gent:regulation to be able to return to this baseline. But yeah,
Rob Gent:wonder your thoughts how much how much of your supervision
Rob Gent:with therapist, so
Katie McCoog:with my team, specifically, I really like to
Katie McCoog:do like weekly supervision, where it's the structured you
Katie McCoog:sit down, and you talk about it. However, building relationships,
Katie McCoog:I think, is incredibly important for any human being to be able
Katie McCoog:to function through any event in their life, right? I mean, we
Katie McCoog:are meaning makers, and we thrive on relationships, and
Katie McCoog:that's developmentally what we need to grow and learn. So with
Katie McCoog:my clinicians, I love having any reason if their doors open, I
Katie McCoog:pop my head in and just say, Hey, how you doing? I need a cup
Katie McCoog:of coffee, want to go for a walk? So there is this
Katie McCoog:structured supervision that's very essential for them to be
Katie McCoog:able to break down and process like countertransference. If
Katie McCoog:there's vicarious trauma, like yes, we have all that and pull
Katie McCoog:them out of that element, and let them know I see you as a
Katie McCoog:human being, and you're allowed to be a huge and being with me.
Katie McCoog:So let's let's get out of this environment, so we can really
Katie McCoog:get to it. Sometimes I feel like people might deflect because
Katie McCoog:they have that unrealistic expectation of themselves like,
Katie McCoog:I'm the therapist, so I should be able to well stop being a
Katie McCoog:therapist for a second. People and let's just talk. Yeah,
Rob Gent:love that. And then how do you notice? Let's just be
Rob Gent:overt about the word. I hear this from therapists all the
Rob Gent:time. I'm feeling burnout. Yeah. And burnout. And I'm always
Rob Gent:curious, what is what is that mean for you? And what are your
Rob Gent:thoughts about that term?
Katie McCoog:Again, I like to just a conversation, because if
Katie McCoog:we were to go by definition, it almost presents is like you're
Katie McCoog:done with the field. burnt out means I'm done. And I can't even
Katie McCoog:bring myself. But what is what is your burn out? And can we
Katie McCoog:define it? And can we rephrase it? I am a big believer that
Katie McCoog:language really helps. You're where you are mentally? And so
Katie McCoog:if you're using burns out, well, then how am I supposed to help
Katie McCoog:you come back around? How are you going to walk into work
Katie McCoog:today, and be present and show up for yourself in the fro your
Katie McCoog:clients? If you're tired? If you need a break? If you need me to
Katie McCoog:step in, like let's start defining and giving that a
Katie McCoog:different language and a different vocabulary than just
Katie McCoog:burns out because burn out to me means you're, you're completely
Katie McCoog:done and you're walking out my door. Instead of Katie, I really
Katie McCoog:need a break. I need help. What do I do I feel lost, I feel
Katie McCoog:detached. I don't know what to do with this case. Like, we get
Katie McCoog:very complex cases. And for you to feel that you just don't know
Katie McCoog:what to do is also okay, maybe you're not burnt out. Maybe you
Katie McCoog:just really need support.
Rob Gent:Well, it seems like I like I really value that you're
Rob Gent:using the term burnout, like I'm picturing this piece of wood
Rob Gent:that literally is burned up and it's got no life left in it. And
Rob Gent:you said, I'm done. And it's interesting how not just
Rob Gent:therapists but I think as people in general, when they're feeling
Rob Gent:this burnout, we have these interesting patterns to kind of
Rob Gent:make the burnout worse, to perpetuate the burnout, rather
Rob Gent:than knowing how to like, step out of it. Yeah. Yeah, maybe
Rob Gent:speak a little bit about have you noticed that before? You
Rob Gent:know,
Katie McCoog:I have, um, I feel like you get stuck. It's almost
Katie McCoog:like tunnel vision, like you can't picture any other way. And
Katie McCoog:maybe the intensity that you are experiencing is burnt out is
Katie McCoog:describing it all in one word. But really, it's so much more,
Katie McCoog:there's so many more layers underneath what the burnt out
Katie McCoog:is, but because you're fixated on burns out on burned out, it's
Katie McCoog:almost Well, what does that mean to you? Are you now I've had
Katie McCoog:some of my clinicians feel like, I'm burned out, I'm a failure.
Katie McCoog:I'm not good enough. What am I doing here? Can I really handle
Katie McCoog:this? And it's, well, yeah, you're a human being, and it's
Katie McCoog:okay to be affected by this stuff. How do we protect
Katie McCoog:ourselves emotionally, which we don't often think of when you go
Katie McCoog:into Sessions, and you hear this complex trauma all the time. So
Katie McCoog:again, like supervision is really important. And sometimes
Katie McCoog:it's your supervisor that has to pull you out of it, because you
Katie McCoog:get stuck, which is very normal.
Rob Gent:You do get stuck. Yeah, we, we've certainly
Rob Gent:noticed that people get stuck and I use the term they
Rob Gent:perpetuate it, they kind of just stay in this burnout mode.
Rob Gent:Oftentimes, we noticed that there's this interesting
Rob Gent:projection of resentment, like my caseload is too high, or it's
Rob Gent:the company or the expectations, or it's the parents or it's, the
Rob Gent:clients are too acute and too demanding. And it just becomes
Rob Gent:this. I would always say that that's a good indicator that you
Rob Gent:know, you're headed towards being overwhelmed or
Rob Gent:overstressed. Personally, I don't. I'm with you, Katie. I
Rob Gent:think you're saying this. I don't like the term burnout.
Rob Gent:Because it does mean there's some finality to it like, I've,
Rob Gent:I've burned up all my fuel, and nothing's left, right. Like,
Rob Gent:actually, I don't think that's actually the case. How do we see
Rob Gent:it as maybe you got overwhelmed or overstressed? And then how do
Rob Gent:we devise ways to mitigate that? And I one thing I wanted to say,
Rob Gent:and I think you mentioned this, was that oftentimes we have this
Rob Gent:expectation that we can perform, and we shouldn't get burnout and
Rob Gent:do this. And we take it as some sort of moral failing. Like,
Rob Gent:it's me as the as the therapist, I just, something's wrong with
Rob Gent:me. I can't do it. And then it gets really convoluted with that
Rob Gent:sense of self doubt. Maybe even shame turns into this
Rob Gent:resentment, and I've heard this and maybe you have to, well, I
Rob Gent:just need a better work life balance.
Katie McCoog:Yeah, sorry I did. I've said that before in my
Katie McCoog:earlier days. Being a therapist. So I don't mean to giggle, but
Katie McCoog:it's like, Oh, it's great for I have definitely felt that
Katie McCoog:before. Like, I need to be more balanced. Okay, but what does
Katie McCoog:that mean? What does that actually mean? You know, is it?
Katie McCoog:Is it the work? Is it? Are you burnt out? Are you blaming and
Katie McCoog:projecting? Like you said, Rob? Or is it I need better
Katie McCoog:boundaries, and I need to feel not as much guilt when I
Katie McCoog:implement my boundaries, because we're teaching other people to
Katie McCoog:have boundaries, we should have been for ourselves too.
Rob Gent:And that's something, certainly if you're a therapist,
Rob Gent:or your clinical director, that should be something that's
Rob Gent:coming up in supervision, yes, to be able to discuss, you know,
Rob Gent:our understanding of Yeah, where, where are our boundaries?
Rob Gent:Why are we feeling overstressed? I? I like the analogy, what
Rob Gent:somebody said to me, people like to say, need a better work life
Rob Gent:balance, but I've rarely ever heard that it's, man, I really
Rob Gent:need to spend way less time with my children or my family, I need
Rob Gent:to spend less time I took way too much vacation this year.
Rob Gent:Right? What? You never hear people say that, what do they
Rob Gent:always say, oh, I need to cut back on work. I need to do that.
Rob Gent:So I like to think about that. Like you're saying maybe it's
Rob Gent:not about balance. It's reconceptualizing. What am I
Rob Gent:doing? what's meaningful? What are what what's exceeding my
Rob Gent:boundaries? Is it creeping into some time that I have away from
Rob Gent:work or parents? Somehow? am I allowing myself to get in
Rob Gent:meshed? Lots of times that comes up, especially when you have
Rob Gent:really demanding high acute kids and parents? Well,
Katie McCoog:I'm what am I? What am I actually in control
Katie McCoog:of? Because sometimes it's if you're here, and you're
Katie McCoog:constantly working, then to have control of the situation, that
Katie McCoog:kid will do better, or the parents will understand or the
Katie McCoog:team will start doing this practice. And it's trust, you
Katie McCoog:know, what are you actually in control of and trusting your
Katie McCoog:team and trusting yourself that you've put the work in and
Katie McCoog:you're doing, you know, really good foundational work with your
Katie McCoog:students and your families that you actually have to give them
Katie McCoog:the opportunity to now practice it themselves beyond you just
Katie McCoog:being there? Take a step back, it's okay to do that.
Rob Gent:So let me ask you, if I'm a therapist, what should I
Rob Gent:bring to my we talk about supervision, super important.
Rob Gent:Having regular meetings with a supervisor, you know, certainly
Rob Gent:if you're in a clinical setting, whoever's your manager should be
Rob Gent:able to approach some of that stuff with you. If you're a
Rob Gent:therapist, what I don't want to do is just a rah, rah them into
Rob Gent:like, oh, you know, here, just try harder and change. I don't
Rob Gent:want to do that. What and I don't I know, you don't either.
Rob Gent:If you're a therapist, what are some things that you might be
Rob Gent:looking for, to recognize that you might be coming?
Rob Gent:overstressed? Or you might be coming, developing some sort of
Rob Gent:overwhelming feelings? Or what are the indicators, some of
Rob Gent:these indicators? If I'm a therapist, or a new therapist?
Rob Gent:What do I look for?
Katie McCoog:Okay, so I will do my best to give some because
Katie McCoog:again, I think that it's, it's really on the individual, but
Katie McCoog:any change in thought, so if you're usually going to work,
Katie McCoog:and you're in a good state of mind, um, most of the time, and
Katie McCoog:then you start kind of dreading work, or you're fixated on what
Katie McCoog:you have to do or worried about how the milieu is going to be
Katie McCoog:today, or I've got a lot of work or, you know, I would pay
Katie McCoog:attention to your thought patterns of that, honestly,
Katie McCoog:because that it's so easy to fall in to it without
Katie McCoog:recognizing it. And so self awareness of how you're even
Katie McCoog:thinking on your way to work is really important. I would like
Katie McCoog:you to remember to eat, it's really really important to eat
Katie McCoog:your lunch if you need a snack, eat
Rob Gent:a healthy lunch. A healthy lunch
Katie McCoog:works. You yes, if you're a coffee drinker or water
Katie McCoog:drinker or something like realize if you've gone a couple
Katie McCoog:of days without eating your lunch. Okay, so what does that
Katie McCoog:say? Because now you're actually neglecting what you need for for
Katie McCoog:your body to function and for you able to do therapy and be
Katie McCoog:present for it. You know, I and I say it because I've actually
Katie McCoog:missed lunch a bunch of times, you know, in a week, so pay
Katie McCoog:attention to like, what are your habits? What are you doing? How
Katie McCoog:are you speaking to other people? You know, what are the
Katie McCoog:words you're using? How do you feel on a client? Can you talk
Katie McCoog:about it with your supervisor? Do you feel uncomfortable with
Katie McCoog:this client or talking about it or ask Do for help? Or how are
Katie McCoog:people responding to you?
Rob Gent:Those are, those are great ones. I like one that you
Rob Gent:mentioned up is recognizing. I always use some Carl Rogers type
Rob Gent:of mindset if I'm shifting out of unconditional positive regard
Rob Gent:for people. And I noticed that I'm getting a little bit short,
Rob Gent:or I'm having inaccurate expectations, or this is coming
Rob Gent:up. For me, I always like to tell therapists, well, if that's
Rob Gent:happening for you, boy, well, you need to talk about because
Rob Gent:that's one of the stepping stones, the gateway into this
Rob Gent:term that you're going to use. I'm, I'm burnout, or if I'm
Rob Gent:leaving work, and I'm slightly resentful, like feeling like,
Rob Gent:ah, that Darren paperwork is just, I know documentation isn't
Rob Gent:fun. Right? But when it's just like I'm behind, and I'm
Rob Gent:procrastinating, I'm not staying on top of it. That's just part
Rob Gent:of the job. Right? Oftentimes, that that's something too
Rob Gent:that's, you're going to, you're going to use the burnout word or
Rob Gent:have that mindset.
Katie McCoog:Yeah, absolutely.
Rob Gent:Great, Katie, those are good ones. I appreciate
Rob Gent:that. So I you talked about relationship, I'd like to bring
Rob Gent:up we'll talk a little bit about flow state, but in your mind,
Rob Gent:how does the therapist mitigate and see that this is reward? How
Rob Gent:do I have more investment than I do withdraw? In my clinical
Rob Gent:practice?
Katie McCoog:Recognizing progress, no matter how big or
Katie McCoog:small and who the progress is, where it's coming from, I think
Katie McCoog:it's those little wins in life that really keep you going. And
Katie McCoog:you have more little wins than grands ones, right? But
Katie McCoog:recognize the progress. And understanding that if you've if
Katie McCoog:you've worked with a family or a client, and or you're working on
Katie McCoog:yourself, and you've been making all this progress, and then all
Katie McCoog:of a sudden you stop, well, is it plateauing? Or is it
Katie McCoog:stabilization, and really think about that, because plateauing
Katie McCoog:could give like a negative thought to it. And stabilization
Katie McCoog:is, well, you're finally not in that negative behavior pattern
Katie McCoog:anymore, regardless of who that is. So recognizing that any
Katie McCoog:progress can be good progress.
Rob Gent:I'm gonna ask a little bit of provocative question,
Rob Gent:because I'm gonna reflect the work of Scott D. Miller, Dr.
Rob Gent:Miller and his group is that how does the therapist and a
Rob Gent:supervisor, how did they actually know that they're
Rob Gent:making progress?
Katie McCoog:Is it the same? What's the same? When I, I like
Katie McCoog:to use data with my clinicians, because they are a little bit
Katie McCoog:more black and white thinkers. And if they listen to this, I
Katie McCoog:love you guys. But they are so they really respond more to like
Katie McCoog:data. And so any movement in our data, if it's moving forward, or
Katie McCoog:if it's not moving backwards, but it's been the same for a
Katie McCoog:couple of weeks, then let's bring that out. And any change
Katie McCoog:that is moving forward for the client or the families is
Katie McCoog:helpful. So
Rob Gent:maybe define I love that you're using the term data.
Rob Gent:If, if I'm just a clinician, I'm doing the standard practice, and
Rob Gent:I'm not gathering a bunch of data. What are mechanisms that
Rob Gent:you use when you use the term data? What are you really
Rob Gent:referring to? So
Katie McCoog:there's data that I like to use for progress with
Katie McCoog:my clinicians, specifically for like, their job roles? So I do
Katie McCoog:like chart audits. And what if we're really struggling to get
Katie McCoog:our notes done on time, because maybe we are feeling
Katie McCoog:overwhelmed. And I do weekly chart audits with them. And I
Katie McCoog:can actually point out like, Okay, last week, maybe you were
Katie McCoog:only 89% on time, but this week, you're doing 98%. So let's talk
Katie McCoog:about the things that worked for you. When it comes to client
Katie McCoog:data, that we we have a lot of surveys that go out that the
Katie McCoog:clients and the families actually answer. And it's their
Katie McCoog:perception of how they're doing and with their symptoms and
Katie McCoog:functioning in their family, at school in their community. And
Katie McCoog:so it'll give us a number. And it's the movement of the number.
Katie McCoog:So do you want me to get into details of each one, like some
Katie McCoog:numbers, you want to be high in some numbers, you're actually
Katie McCoog:you're doing golf, you want them to be low? And so when these
Katie McCoog:specific surveys are showing us like, well, this is where the
Katie McCoog:clients coming in at their baseline, and then what's the
Katie McCoog:movement happening after they've been with us for a little bit?
Katie McCoog:So that's the type of data that we collect.
Rob Gent:Yeah, I appreciate that. And just giving some
Rob Gent:specificity to it is, for an example is where you would
Rob Gent:administer Depression Inventory, or you would do in anxiety and
Rob Gent:these are validated instruments, be it the PHQ nine or the GAD
Rob Gent:seven or Even a measurement of well being like the WHO five,
Rob Gent:you're administering this, while youth outcomes questionnaire you
Rob Gent:actually have the parents do them as well. Yes, yeah. So
Rob Gent:actually, what I'm hearing you say, Kate is, those measurements
Rob Gent:give the client a voice. And that's a really great way to see
Rob Gent:it on number of actual data on progress. Because let's let's be
Rob Gent:real. Sessions can be hit or miss. And we think they went
Rob Gent:really well or really bad. And the actual client might have a
Rob Gent:different experience, or the parents might have a different
Rob Gent:experience.
Katie McCoog:What I love so much also about the service that
Katie McCoog:we use is, very often we have people come to our program that
Katie McCoog:they, they feel a certain way, and they don't know how to put
Katie McCoog:it into words. And so how do you then find a baseline? How do you
Katie McCoog:then know what we're going to work on? How do we know what the
Katie McCoog:dysfunction of the family is and how to help like healthier
Katie McCoog:attachments and relationships with mom or dad or, you know,
Katie McCoog:whoever the caregiver is, and you don't know how to
Katie McCoog:communicate it, because maybe you've never learned it, which,
Katie McCoog:okay, that happens. So this survey actually gives us a
Katie McCoog:really great picture of, oh, so with a PHQ nine, which is your
Katie McCoog:depression survey, this person might have an elevated number
Katie McCoog:nine, which is like suicidal ideation is fleeting, or it's,
Katie McCoog:it's there, it's very present. But you don't know how to tell
Katie McCoog:anybody, because you just never learned it. Maybe you just felt
Katie McCoog:so awful that like it's you're blocking the ability to even
Katie McCoog:understand and absorb what you're learning in the past. So
Katie McCoog:it gives us a really good picture of understanding like
Katie McCoog:maybe where they're at. And then we start there, and then help
Katie McCoog:teach them how to communicate their thoughts and feelings
Katie McCoog:through that.
Rob Gent:I'm really smiling, because it's such a beautiful
Rob Gent:thing that I don't think most people think it's
Rob Gent:counterintuitive, like actually, using objective data will
Rob Gent:actually help to reduce this term burnout. Like, it's
Rob Gent:actually objective, it takes some of this objective, am I
Rob Gent:doing good? Am I not? I mean, it is just really amazing that we
Rob Gent:actually can use that objectiveness to weave in to
Rob Gent:increase resiliency, because now we can see it more objectively.
Rob Gent:That's about Katie, really, really, I love that we got into,
Rob Gent:like, wow, using using data, and we actually, there's actually a
Rob Gent:therapeutic alliance scale that's used to maybe talk a
Rob Gent:little bit about that. Why? Why would that help therapists,
Katie McCoog:so the therapeutic alliance scale, we have students
Katie McCoog:fill out their own survey, and we have, um, each caregiver
Katie McCoog:involves fill out their own survey from their perception.
Katie McCoog:And it also helps kind of tell the story. Honestly, the the
Katie McCoog:outcome tools that we use is like a storyboard for me so I
Katie McCoog:can understand. So you know, you could have a drop in therapeutic
Katie McCoog:alliance, meaning how well do I feel like I am heard or
Katie McCoog:connected to my therapist or the staff at the program? And if
Katie McCoog:there's a dip after, it's been pretty great. To me, I like to
Katie McCoog:look at that and talk about it, because the therapists often
Katie McCoog:think, oh, my gosh, what am I doing wrong? They don't like me?
Katie McCoog:And will. When do you have your family session? Because I'm
Katie McCoog:looking at these other tools? And did you? Did you hit a
Katie McCoog:button that maybe they haven't uncovered that topic before?
Katie McCoog:Because that could be? Oh, like, that's the nicest way to say it,
Katie McCoog:the family could feel like, why don't like this therapist, and
Katie McCoog:then they do drop in it. But maybe you're actually onto
Katie McCoog:something. So you don't actually want the therapeutic alliance
Katie McCoog:score to be high all the time. Because then we're not really
Katie McCoog:doing our job, we, we need to push the envelope and help them
Katie McCoog:discover what the core issues are. And in order for actual
Katie McCoog:healing to happen, you don't want to mask it. No band aids,
Katie McCoog:what's really going on? Let's get to the core of it. I told my
Katie McCoog:families, if you don't tell me you hate me, at least once, I'm
Katie McCoog:not doing a very good job.
Rob Gent:But if you don't have the maturity of the experience,
Rob Gent:or the objective data to know that you as a new therapist, you
Rob Gent:might take it personally and like oh, everybody, everybody
Rob Gent:hates me. My job's terrible. I'm not doing a good job. I thought
Rob Gent:it was all about, you know, making people feel warm and
Rob Gent:fuzzies. And you're saying, Actually, that's not it. This is
Rob Gent:a different paradigm shift. Let's use objective data. And if
Rob Gent:I'm hearing you, Katie, you're also saying that whole process
Rob Gent:of doing surveys and all of that gives us a clear roadmap when
Rob Gent:we're looking at treatment. So it actually gives us a more
Rob Gent:accurate prescription and a more accurate roadmap that actually
Rob Gent:is incredibly impactful for the therapist to have confidence and
Rob Gent:not feel like it's this willy nilly subjective thing and I'm
Rob Gent:bearing all the responsibility of it. Yeah. So, wow, one
Rob Gent:incredible way to work on resiliency is to use the
Rob Gent:measures and use more objective means to be able to do that.
Rob Gent:Really terrific. Yeah. I really appreciate that. Well, along
Rob Gent:those lines, I wanted to mention that doing therapeutic alliance,
Rob Gent:I mentioned Scott Miller before and when we talk about
Rob Gent:resiliency is often or reward or feeling burnout is often linked
Rob Gent:to therapist overestimate their effectiveness by somewhat like
Rob Gent:over the last 40 years, almost 85%, we overestimate our
Rob Gent:effectiveness. And at the end of the day, it really is about
Rob Gent:looking at patient outcomes long term, okay. And Scott Miller's
Rob Gent:work and his colleagues in particular, all of their
Rob Gent:research indicated that the therapeutic alliance was the
Rob Gent:greatest percentage and greatest variance for actually affecting
Rob Gent:that, that change, it wasn't specific to, I think the
Rob Gent:modality in the intervention was less than 1% of the variance of
Rob Gent:change. So I'm just pushing on the fact that knowing the
Rob Gent:numbers, but really examining the relationship has the
Rob Gent:greatest impact, not only in client outcomes, but I would
Rob Gent:imagine for the therapists sense of success and competence, as
Rob Gent:well.
Katie McCoog:Yeah, I agree. It's funny, because we we use
Katie McCoog:modalities, I find a lot of our families ask us, you know, the
Katie McCoog:modalities that we use here at the program, and I understand
Katie McCoog:why, because to them, it's like a comfort of trying to
Katie McCoog:understand what's going to help their child and it, the
Katie McCoog:modalities are important, right? We want to teach these skills,
Katie McCoog:but you can't learn skills from somebody you don't trust, you're
Katie McCoog:not really going to learn it, you're not going to absorb it,
Katie McCoog:you may not even listen to it. So why would you want to work
Katie McCoog:with somebody become vulnerable, and start really digging through
Katie McCoog:all of this stuff, if you don't trust the person in front of
Katie McCoog:you. So it really is relationship based? And we get
Katie McCoog:to use all these other tools as well.
Rob Gent:It really value that. Yeah, thank you. Thank you.
Rob Gent:Well, let's talk a little bit. We talked about ways to mitigate
Rob Gent:it, I would just like to touch on a few things. When we talked
Rob Gent:about being a therapist, I always like to ask the question.
Rob Gent:As a therapist, one of the greatest ways to prevent this
Rob Gent:burnout or this sense of resentment is what's filling
Rob Gent:your well, or what's what's rewarding to you. I don't know
Rob Gent:how you approach that with with your team. But I always like to
Rob Gent:maybe your thoughts on that. Katie is D, how do you know your
Rob Gent:clinicians? Or what's rewarding for them?
Katie McCoog:Well, knowing your what, or your why, you know,
Katie McCoog:depending on what theory you're coming from, but like what, what
Katie McCoog:brought you into this field in the first place? And how are you
Katie McCoog:working towards this goal, I think is really important. So
Katie McCoog:knowing if it's fulfilling or not any progress at all, that's
Katie McCoog:going towards your what I think brings them back. So knowing
Katie McCoog:your what is really important, knowing
Rob Gent:your what knowing your why I have found maybe you too
Rob Gent:is that somehow people get into this field thinking this this
Rob Gent:altruistic life that I'm going to leave of just giving, giving
Rob Gent:give where I noticed those are the people who usually have
Rob Gent:nothing left to give very quickly, right? Like the well,
Rob Gent:the well becomes empty pretty quick. And I'm always like, no,
Rob Gent:let's change the framework, it actually this is you need to be
Rob Gent:simultaneously growing and experiencing that growth, like
Rob Gent:you mentioned before, and progress, as well as your
Rob Gent:clients. And so I don't know, I always like to bring up this
Rob Gent:term, I'm not sure how familiar you are with flow state, if
Rob Gent:familiar with flow state. So flow state has been a long time
Rob Gent:studied, it's this, I'll give you the three criteria. But flow
Rob Gent:state is something that when you're doing it, there's three
Rob Gent:criteria, that time transfer, there's a time transformation,
Rob Gent:you kind of forget about time, time disappears when you're
Rob Gent:doing a certain activity. The next one is that you're
Rob Gent:appropriately challenged, your skill set is appropriately
Rob Gent:challenged, where you're not overly challenged, or you're not
Rob Gent:under challenged. And then the final one is called unambiguous
Rob Gent:feedback. So I always like to bring up for anybody say chi,
Rob Gent:what's an activity that you do that gets you into that flow
Rob Gent:state? Can you think of one for you, Katie, I know I've talked
Rob Gent:to a lot of people that like my son's a rock climber. He's like,
Rob Gent:Dad, I love rock climbing. And we talked about it actually gets
Rob Gent:him into the flow state time disappears. He gets immediate
Rob Gent:feedback doesn't mean like you make a wrong hold. You
Rob Gent:immediately get the feedback, which is great. And he's
Rob Gent:appropriately challenged. He actually doesn't do the climbing
Rob Gent:that's exceeds his ability or else he would get frustrated
Rob Gent:with the activity. So I don't know if there's something for
Rob Gent:you, that gets you into that flow state.
Katie McCoog:Well, I really hope you believe me when I say
Katie McCoog:I'm residential, being here. Yeah. My, my kids, you know, my
Katie McCoog:kids, the clients hear sorry, but when they come, it's family.
Katie McCoog:Time, time does kind of disappear, you get really sucked
Katie McCoog:into the environment and what you're doing and why you're
Katie McCoog:doing it. And I told them that I haven't worked a day in my life.
Katie McCoog:So my flow state is being here.
Rob Gent:Yeah, and so on. Now, I like to put a label to it. And
Rob Gent:I love that you're saying it's actually being in this
Rob Gent:therapeutic environment is that flow state for you, that
Rob Gent:actually, you don't leave and say, Gosh, I work too many hours
Rob Gent:today, like I'm just resentful that I, I worked so many hours,
Rob Gent:it's not about that the time actually disappears. And you're
Rob Gent:appropriately challenged, right.
Katie McCoog:But more than others serve
Rob Gent:some some days more than others, certainly, but, and
Rob Gent:then you're constantly getting feedback from the clients, yes.
Rob Gent:And the therapist, and it's unambiguous. It is so clear. So
Rob Gent:I like to bring that up. So now we have a construct, especially
Rob Gent:for those people listening or might be Clinical Directors, or
Rob Gent:therapists or professionals, to be able to recognize that I
Rob Gent:always like to say, to bring it up in supervision that a
Rob Gent:therapist should be doing therapy that they actually enter
Rob Gent:into this flow state. Because flow state, as you know, as we
Rob Gent:defined it, you're saying, I don't really count it as work, I
Rob Gent:counted as a integrated part of myself. Yes. And you're not
Rob Gent:dividing it out. And that's ideally what we would want for
Rob Gent:our therapist, to be able to recognize and identify Well, I'm
Rob Gent:actually in this flow state, where it's rewarding for me. And
Rob Gent:I have appropriate challenges, I meet the criteria. And that's,
Rob Gent:I'm grateful for it, rather than resentful for.
Katie McCoog:Absolutely. Once you start becoming resentful
Katie McCoog:than I think we're starting to walk down that path of we're
Katie McCoog:very overtired. And using the burnout term, yeah.
Rob Gent:And not that you're gonna be in flow all the time.
Rob Gent:That doesn't happen. It's not flow all the time, but a little
Rob Gent:bit of flow, because I'm amazed at how many people even from
Rob Gent:clinicians, you ask them about flow, and there is no flow. They
Rob Gent:can't identify. And then you know, the reason I wanted to
Rob Gent:bring up that's a huge red flag, right? If there's no recognition
Rob Gent:or awareness of entering in a meeting this criteria flow
Rob Gent:state, I can guarantee you how long are they going to last?
Rob Gent:Right? They aren't going to last. So thanks for letting me
Rob Gent:bring that up. I really appreciate it. I think that's
Rob Gent:one of those things that I want to make sure that we give some
Rob Gent:resources to therapist and Clinical Directors to recognize,
Rob Gent:gosh, am I getting burnout? What should it feel like? How should
Rob Gent:it be rewarding? I think I think that's important. Well, Katie
Rob Gent:thinks about that. So let's shift gears just a little bit.
Rob Gent:Now that we understand we're talking about flow state, and
Rob Gent:you've done so well to articulate Hey, some things to
Rob Gent:be aware of and all that. Let's dive into vicarious trauma,
Rob Gent:because this is one that as in the helping profession,
Rob Gent:especially one like ours. We knew it going into it, didn't
Rob Gent:we? Yes. It wasn't like some surprise that, like, I'm gonna
Rob Gent:listen to people's troubles and their trauma, and all of this.
Rob Gent:So maybe a little talk a little bit about Katie, how you like to
Rob Gent:conceptualize vicarious trauma, and how that shows up with your
Rob Gent:clinicians and with your practice,
Katie McCoog:I think, um, I mean, sometimes it's completely
Katie McCoog:evident to a person and they really feel it. They take it
Katie McCoog:home with them, it's an thoughts. It's you're trying to
Katie McCoog:cook dinner, and you're already thinking about maybe the things
Katie McCoog:that you've heard today, and it's really affecting you, and
Katie McCoog:you're not functioning as you used to. And sometimes I think
Katie McCoog:that it's not, I think that vicarious trauma can be
Katie McCoog:something that happens over time that you don't actually
Katie McCoog:recognize that you're experiencing until you have
Katie McCoog:someone from the outside say, are you okay? Because you don't
Katie McCoog:seen yourself lately or whatever that looks like for you. And so
Katie McCoog:I think it's important for people to recognize that I mean,
Katie McCoog:to me I of course, I broken into like two things very simply. But
Katie McCoog:sometimes you really feel it and it's in your face and you can
Katie McCoog:avoid and you're, oh my gosh, I don't know if I can work with
Katie McCoog:this case, because I'm having countertransference and
Katie McCoog:sometimes it's I've been working with maybe a specific population
Katie McCoog:for so long that I not recognizing that I'm now
Katie McCoog:becoming reactive to my clients instead of responding to them.
Katie McCoog:treating everybody as though this is the population, whether
Katie McCoog:it's colleagues, it's clients, it's outside people, you're at
Katie McCoog:the grocery store. So vicarious trauma to me is, it can be
Katie McCoog:sneaky. It's really important to have a relationship with
Katie McCoog:somebody that you work with that can kind of help you make sure
Katie McCoog:that like, you're regulating it, and you're really monitoring it
Katie McCoog:because especially in trauma therapy, you hear so much, or
Katie McCoog:you see so much, but recognizing what do you need for yourself to
Katie McCoog:just say emotionally protective?
Rob Gent:Yeah, create definition. To add on to what
Rob Gent:you're saying is that vicarious trauma, I like to add this piece
Rob Gent:for most people is that it's a, it's a result of cumulative
Rob Gent:exposure from somebody else's traumatic experience that I like
Rob Gent:to say, it's sort of like you said, sneaky, I'll use an old
Rob Gent:school analogy of the frog and the frog in the boiling water.
Rob Gent:We as therapists, you know, the frog, you put them in some
Rob Gent:lukewarm water, you turn up the heat, it boils, and the frog
Rob Gent:doesn't know to jump out. And before it knows that it will
Rob Gent:actually be in the boiling water to its own detriment. I think as
Rob Gent:therapists you're saying kind of the same thing. We're the same
Rob Gent:way. We're just we're hearing it, we're taking it in, we think
Rob Gent:that we're dealing with it. But all of a sudden, like trauma
Rob Gent:does, it starts to show itself and all kinds of peripherial
Rob Gent:auxilary ways. Maybe even somatically, I'm feeling
Rob Gent:tension, or I'm not like to say maybe I'm not eating right, or
Rob Gent:my movement is or I'm getting headaches, or whatever it is. So
Rob Gent:there's all this trauma that can be experienced. And we as
Rob Gent:therapists have to know that it's actually part of our job.
Rob Gent:Yeah. Like we are primed, susceptible. I mean, it's like
Rob Gent:being firemen, but we have to go into the fire every single day.
Rob Gent:Right? Yeah. So something to be aware of, in that. It's amazing
Rob Gent:how much of that exists, maybe you're saying this to that
Rob Gent:exists sometimes underneath the surface in a pre conscious way
Rob Gent:for a therapist. And then sometimes it manifests in way,
Rob Gent:like I'm getting irritated or I'm burnout. When they don't
Rob Gent:even recognize, gosh, it's actually a build up of all of
Rob Gent:this vicarious trauma and vicarious stress that I've that
Rob Gent:I've endured. Yeah. So I really appreciate talking about it.
Rob Gent:Because I think it's important that it's oftentimes burnout is
Rob Gent:a cumulative effect of a bunch of different things.
Katie McCoog:Absolutely. And I don't, I'm sorry, I'm just gonna
Katie McCoog:say I don't feel like anybody is truly immune to it either. So I
Katie McCoog:gotta say, like, when I was, you know, entering this field about
Katie McCoog:17 years ago, I definitely went in with like, Nope, I'm fine.
Katie McCoog:Like, it's not going to affect me. And yeah, no, it really
Katie McCoog:does. So, don't think that anyone is immune to it, there's
Katie McCoog:no special thing to stay, you're, you're going to be
Katie McCoog:affected, especially when you put your heart into something.
Katie McCoog:And you're in your flow state, you're going to get affected by
Katie McCoog:it. And it's okay, but like, how do you take care of yourself?
Katie McCoog:That's a really important question to constantly evaluate.
Katie McCoog:So
Rob Gent:maybe we can give as we close, Katie, this has been
Rob Gent:so helpful to talk about maybe we can give some specific
Rob Gent:things. I always like to tell even Clinical Directors or
Rob Gent:anybody in the field. Boy, mentorship is really key.
Rob Gent:mentorship, absolutely is a primary thing, what are some
Rob Gent:other things you would say are real, specific things to do? In
Rob Gent:the field.
Katie McCoog:I feel like I've said this a couple of times. And
Katie McCoog:I'll just keep saying it because it's part of my practice of who
Katie McCoog:I am as a social worker. But relationships are incredibly
Katie McCoog:important to me. So having a great supervision, very
Katie McCoog:intentional about it, having strong relationships with people
Katie McCoog:that you have someone to go and talk to, and and be able to
Katie McCoog:share that with therapists. I am a big believer that therapists
Katie McCoog:should have therapists, because who else can you say all of this
Katie McCoog:to and really lay it all out on the line and feel that
Katie McCoog:protection and that comfort and the openness and the space to do
Katie McCoog:it, having boundaries, knowing them and trying to feel minimal
Katie McCoog:guilt when you implement your boundaries? And we at least I
Katie McCoog:speak for myself, sometimes I feel guilty when I say no, I
Katie McCoog:can't do this right now because it's a boundary for me that I
Katie McCoog:need a break. But understanding that it's important for me to
Katie McCoog:take it or I won't be able to show up the best way that I can
Katie McCoog:show up usually.
Rob Gent:And I can't support you enough to say structure and
Rob Gent:boundaries is necessary to actually have accurate empathy.
Rob Gent:This isn't a process. Therapy is so much integrated on empathy in
Rob Gent:with burnout, with having vicarious trauma. Those are
Rob Gent:things that erode our empathy. And then we tend to, we can get
Rob Gent:in meshed and start to feel so I love the kid, you're saying, no,
Rob Gent:no, you got to have structure, you've got to have some
Rob Gent:boundaries, and get some relationships that support that,
Rob Gent:right? And I'm saying, Get into a mentorship or a supervisory
Rob Gent:relationship, or get with a therapist, if you know that to
Rob Gent:help monitor it. Because if you don't monitor it, it often grows
Rob Gent:like a weed. And then before you know it, you don't want to be in
Rob Gent:the profession, or else you're trying to figure out how to get
Rob Gent:a better work life balance, and then it kind of spins out in the
Rob Gent:burnout just never goes away. And then your eyes how many
Rob Gent:times I've seen therapists take vacations. And this is going to
Rob Gent:heal my burnout. And actually, they come back and about three
Rob Gent:days later, right back, right back to it and the vacation
Rob Gent:magically didn't do anything. Rather than here. Do all these
Rob Gent:other things.
Katie McCoog:It's a constant process. Yeah.
Rob Gent:Katie, this been so incredible. Thank you so much.
Rob Gent:Any final words to in regards to this clinical resilience thing
Rob Gent:we've been talking about? It's been so helpful today.
Katie McCoog:It's okay to not be okay. As long as you go help
Katie McCoog:for it.
Rob Gent:Really well said. Appreciate that. Katie,
Rob Gent:everybody, thank you. Thank you so much for your time. This is
Rob Gent:such an important topic, especially with all that's going
Rob Gent:on in the world with levels of anxiety and depression. And we
Rob Gent:know that there's conflict happening everywhere. I mean,
Rob Gent:who's who's not feeling a little bit overwhelmed and can
Rob Gent:certainly feel some burnout. So those have been super incredibly
Rob Gent:helpful tips. I appreciate so much your time, Katie, and thank
Rob Gent:you for all the listeners. Thank you for listening to Sessions.
Rob Gent:And doing that. Please access these podcasts wherever you
Rob Gent:access podcasts are great. So look forward to seeing everybody
Rob Gent:next time. Bye bye